Are you familiar with dal makhani? It’s a rich, spiced, lentil-based stew made for special occasions in India (especially in the Punjab region in northern India). Someday, I hope to travel there and taste it for myself. Maybe next year, if I’m lucky.
For now, I’ll enjoy this dal makhani at home. Dal makhani traditionally takes quite a long time to make, starting with soaking the lentils and then cooking them for hours on the stove (or more quickly in a pressure cooker). It’s often reserved for special occasions, like birthdays and holidays.
I couldn’t find traditional whole black lentils (urad dal) in grocery stores, so I used regular black lentils instead, which cook much faster. I also used canned kidney beans rather than dried, so this dish only requires about 45 minutes on the stove.
Dal makhani is generally made creamy with lots of butter and cream, but I stole a trick from my favorite lentil soup to make this creamy—I blended up about two cups of the cooked stew and stirred it back into the pot. The starchy lentils get nice and creamy that way.
You’re welcome to stir in cream (or coconut milk) at the end, if you’d like, but it dulls the flavor a bit. If you order this dish at a restaurant, it will probably arrive with a beautiful swirl of cream on top.
Since this dish is rich, the spices in this recipe are more subtle. Garam masala is a warming spice blend made with cardamom, cinnamon, cloves, cumin, black pepper and coriander. Indian cooking typically starts by dry-toasting whole spices, but I cheated and used a ground spice blend.
Frontier Co-op’s blend smells and tastes so fresh that I don’t feel like I’m missing out. Great spices really do make a difference, and I feel so spoiled with a spice drawer full of Frontier products.
Ground coriander (made from the seeds of the cilantro plant) and cumin liven up the dish, and a splash of lime at the end works wonders. If you’re craving a creamy, curried, satisfying stew, this is exactly that!
PrintQuick Dal Makhani
- Author:
- Prep Time: 15 minutes
- Cook Time: 45 minutes
- Total Time: 1 hour
- Yield: 4 servings 1x
- Category: Stew
- Method: Stovetop
- Cuisine: Indian
This dal makhani is rich, creamy and loaded with flavor. It’s also lighter and quicker to make than other recipes! Recipe yields 4 servings.
Ingredients
- 2 tablespoons avocado oil or extra-virgin olive oil
- 1 medium yellow onion, chopped
- 3 cloves garlic, pressed or minced
- 1 tablespoon minced fresh ginger
- 1 jalapeño pepper, seeds and membranes removed, minced
- 1 ½ teaspoons Frontier Co-op garam masala*
- ½ teaspoon Frontier Co-op ground cumin
- ½ teaspoon Frontier Co-op ground coriander
- ½ teaspoon salt
- Freshly ground black pepper
- 1 can (15 ounces) diced tomatoes (preferably the fire-roasted variety), with their juices
- 1 cup uncooked black lentils (also called beluga lentils)**, picked over for debris
- 1 can (15 ounces) kidney beans, rinsed and drained, or 1 ½ cups cooked kidney beans
- 5 cups water
- 1 bay leaf
- 1 tablespoon lime juice, plus additional lime wedges for serving
- Optional (for additional creaminess): half-and-half, or regular or light coconut milk
- Chopped fresh cilantro, for garnish
- Suggested accompaniments: cooked brown basmati rice or toasted naan
Instructions
- In a large pot or Dutch oven over medium-high heat, warm the oil until shimmering. Add the onion, garlic, ginger and jalapeño, and cook until softened, stirring occasionally, about 4 to 6 minutes.
- Stir in the garam masala, cumin, coriander and salt. Season generously with black pepper. Cook, while stirring, for 1 minute.
- Add the tomatoes and cook for 1 more minute, while stirring. Add the lentils, kidney beans, water and bay leaf. Raise the heat to medium-high and bring the mixture to a simmer. Reduce the heat to medium-low and simmer until the lentils are nice and tender, stirring occasionally, about 35 minutes.
- Remove the bay leaf. Transfer 2 cups of the mixture (make sure to get some liquid with the lentils) to a blender. Securely fasten the lid. Blend until smooth, about 1 minute, being careful to avoid the hot steam rising from the blender lid.
- Transfer the blended mixture back to the pot and stir to combine. Add the lime juice and season to taste with salt (I usually add ½ teaspoon) and pepper. If you would like to temper the flavor and make the mixture even more creamy, stir in a splash of half-and-half or coconut milk, to taste.
- Serve in bowls, with chopped cilantro and a lime wedge on top. If desired, serve rice or naan on the side. Leftovers keep well, refrigerated, for up to 5 days.
Notes
Make it dairy free/vegan: Use coconut milk instead of half-and-half, or use none at all.
*Change it up: While untraditional, I also love this recipe with regular curry powder instead of garam masala.
**Lentil note: This recipe is not designed for traditional urad dal (whole black gram lentils), which take forever to cook. Standard lentils (the brownish/greenish kind) will work in place of the black lentils. Just keep an eye on them, since they may be done cooking about 5 to 10 minutes sooner.
▸ Nutrition Information
This post was created in partnership with Frontier Co-op and I received compensation for my participation. Opinions are my own, always. Thank you for supporting the sponsors who support C+K!
Roshni
I deeply appreciate your efforts to describe the history and different varieties of dal makhani alongside your own interpretation. It means a lot, especially when I’ve seen so many other food bloggers exhibit behavior that toes the line of cultural appropriation. This (among many other reasons) is why I love Cookie + Kate.
Kate
Thank you so much, Roshni. I’m always trying to be respectful of traditional dishes as I present “my” version. I really appreciate your feedback!
Alli
Could I use fresh tomatoes and If so how many??
Thank you!
★★★★★
Kate
Hi Alli, I’m not sure without trying it. Sorry!
Kilee
Agreed!
Kylie
I’ve never tasted Dal Makhani myself, but I love Indian cuisine and in trying new food in general.
I also happen to have a jar of garam masala lying around that has been begging for a new recipe!
Thank you so much! I can’t wait to try this!
★★★★★
Kate
Thanks, Kylie! This recipe is a perfect use for some of that garam masala. Hope you love it!
April
There were no black lentils at the store, will green subsitute?
Kate
Hi April, yes, they will work!
April Heckman
Thanks! Making this tomorrow and I can’t wait.. :)
April
This recipe was AMAZING!! thank you!
Breanne
This looks very cozy – looking forward to trying it!
Kate
Thank you! Hope you love it, Breanne!
Breanne
Made this last night – it was so good! Most people say it was so good there were no leftovers. Well, we had a lot of leftovers (I think it makes more than 4 servings). But that’s great because now I get to eat it for lunch for the next few days. :) Thanks Kate! These recipes are helping me explore different spices and flavors in my cooking.
★★★★★
Danica
This is so easy and good! I used regular brown lentils, didn’t puree any of it, and it turned out fine.
★★★★
Kate
Thanks, Danica! I’m so glad you enjoyed it.
Tina Davis
I wanted to cook something that didn’t require a trip to the grocery store, so I made this tonight. I previously found the black lentils at Whole foods. This came together quickly and was delish. Great recipe. I ate two servings and the house smelled wonderful from cooking it.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you, Tina! Delighted to hear that you enjoyed this one. Thank you for your comment and your star rating!
Gaby Dalkin
SO flavorful!!
Heather E.
My first adventure with cooking Indian food was the Tikka Masala in your book. My husband, daughter and I LOVED it. So I figured there was a good chance we’d like this too. I used extra-virgin olive oil, omitted any milk and the cilantro. It smelled wonderful and tasted amazing. I heated up leftovers tonight and served over rice with naan.
Kate
Heather, so glad your family is enjoying my variations on Indian dishes! Thank you for letting me know!
JG
I love dal makhani and have been on an Indian kick lately! I’m back to no-processed food & vegan, so I was just looking for some healthy vegan Indian recipes. Can’t believe you just posted this. Definitely going to try this soon. Do you think I could use red lentils or green lentils (I already have them on hand)?
Kate
Hi JG! I’m sorry for the delay. I think the green lentils will work. I just added a recipe note to make that more clear!
Donna Bajek
I made this Dal recipe a few days ago and it is sooo.. delicious! My daughter at it for breakfast, lunch and dinner. SUCCESS!! I only made a few minor changes. I didn’t have kidney beans so I substituted black beans and I used a quart of chicken stock for added flavor. (I wonder how vegetable broth would task?) And, I left the seeds and ribs in on half of the jalapeno and added a 1/4 t. asafoetida (Indian spice). Thank you so much.. a new favorite!
★★★★★
Kate
Donna, thank you! I’m so glad you enjoyed this one!
Yvonne
This was really yummy and fairly quick and easy to make! I used vegetable broth rather than the water (1/2 carton- it was already opened in the fridge). I used Puy Lentils as I didn’t have/couldn’t find black lentils at my local stores. I will make it again thank you!
Kate
Thank you, Yvonne! Delighted to hear it!
Z
Hi! Thanks for this! Quick question: Can this recipe be made with white lentils too (basically the black lentils but pealed)?
Kate
You could try it! I would be sure to follow the cooking instructions for that specific variety.
Evgenia
Very good. Second recipe from your site and again success!
I did some substitutes and adjustments, e.g. used mung beans instead of black lentils (in my city I did not saw anything like that) and instead of dices tomato used whole (that what I had at home). As I was cooking to my toddlers from spices i I’ve adeed only garam masala and it turned out well!
So feel so lucky that I’ve found your site)))
★★★★★
Kate
I’m glad you enjoyed it! Thank you for taking the time to review.
Maria
I borrow that blending half of the ingredients to up the creaminess trick all the time!! I think I first came across it in one of your recipes:) Its the best. I love dal but am not familiar with this Punjab version. I have a close friend from the region but he is allergic to lentils, which he jokes makes him a bad Indian. Nonetheless, I am excited to give this a try. It looks so so hearty and rich.
Kate
Haha, I like your friend’s sense of humor! I’m glad you appreciate that blending trick—it makes such a big difference sometimes!
Josie
This is a fantastic recipe, I loved it as did my whole family.Thank you and keep them coming, you are an inspiration.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you, Josie! I really appreciate your feedback. :)
Madeline
This was wonderful! I couldn’t find black lentils, so used regular green lentils. Still so delicious. Filling and flavorful, like all of your recipes! Thanks for another great one.
★★★★★
Kate
Thanks, Madeline! I’m glad to hear that regular lentils worked well. Hooray!
Diana
I pretty much LOVE all Indian cuisine. I am planning on making this tomorrow with black lentils (urad) I found at the Indian market. Question: Your cook time says 45 minutes using canned kidney beans…I am using canned as well, however, even the gal at the Indian market said that I should use a pressure cooker for the black lentils or else it would be a few hours to cook on the stove. Thoughts?
Susan
I just made this tonight using the urad dal, and 35 minutes wasn’t nearly enough cooking time. Wish I had known.
Ashton
This is delicious! I added a small cinnamon stick and a bit of cardamom for some extra depth, and used some coconut milk for creaminess like you suggested. The leftovers are even better! I’ll be making a double batch next time.
★★★★★
Kate
Leftovers are usually better, right?! Thank you, Ashton for your review :)
Mark
I have eaten a lot of Dal in my travels over the years and this is simple to make and has great flavors, it was a big hit. I made it and liked it so much I shared the recipe with some friends. I added some zucchini (large cubed), red bell peppers and fresh spinach at the end (I like my veggies crunchy) to make a complete meal.
I was able to get the whole black lentils at my local coop.
Another great recipe…
★★★★★
Kate
Mark, that is wonderful to hear! Thank you for your detailed feedback and review!
Lauren
I tried this tonight, and it was a hit with my family, even the kids! I left out the beans and added in a bit more lentils and used fresh tomatoes instead. We made it in the Instant Pot in about 15 minutes and served it with some brown rice. Thanks Kate! :)
★★★★★
Kate
Awesome, Lauren! I am glad it was a hit! Thank you for sharing and for your review :)
Elise
Kate you’re an absolute GENIUS! I love this dish so much, and my local takeaway does dal makhani really well but it’s full of ghee and cream so I always feel guilty ordering it, plus it’s quite heavy. I’ve always wanted to try making my own but have been intimidated by the time and number of rich ingredients required by some recipes. Your version is so much simpler and healthier – but equally as tasty. I used blended silken tofu with some of the bean mixture to make it ultra creamy and it was delish! Thanks :)
Kate
You are so kind, Elise! I am happy you enjoyed it so much. If you would like to provide a star review, that would be great!
April Heckman
This recipe was amaaaazing! Loved the tip of putting a little bit in the blender to make it creamy. Served w/ naan and rice and I cannot wait to make it again!!
★★★★★
Kate
That’s great, April! Happy you enjoyed it and thank you for the review!
Devon
Cooking this as I type! I could have sworn I had more than just red lentils in the pantry, but… I guess I’ll let you know how it turns out with red lentils. Ha.
Kate
Enjoy, Devon! Let me know how it went for you.
Devon
The lentils didn’t really hold up, but the flavor was on point so I didn’t mind. I think I’ll double the beans next time too. Great recipe!
Amanda
I made this for dinner tonight and it was AMAZING. It ended up not being quite flavorful enough, so I went back and added some more of the aromatics (it is entirely possible some of my spices were old). I also added a dash of cayenne to give it a little bit of heat. This was the most guilt-free comfort food I have ever had. Thanks, Kate!
★★★★★
Kate
Thanks, Amanda for your review! You may be onto something with spices being to old with not getting as much flavor. Or, if they aren’t sealed all the way, I have found mine to loose some of their flavor. But I am happy it still worked out so well for you!
Hannah Turner
I honestly was not expecting this to have enough spices, but the amounts were perfect. Regular coconut milk drizzled in at the end was a must. I plan to devour many hot bowls of this during our cold, rainy winter in Portland.
★★★★★
Kate
Great to hear, Hannah! It is a great dish to have during cold days for sure. I appreciate the star review!
char
hi kate, i’ve made this deliciousness twice now and it’s sooooo good. the last time was when my husband’s indian family came over for dinner and they all raved about it! they figured i had been cooking it all day long. the only adjustments i made was i soaked my lentils first and added a little extra spice. it’s a wonderful recipe that received high, high praise from my in-laws. i highly recommend it to anyone who loves dal.
Kate
That is great! Thank you, Char for sharing.
Eleanor
I just had one of those Mondays, where I’m screwing up left and right, traffic’s bad, the grocery store is crowded and … of course, I get home and in the middle of this recipe, realize that I forgot the kidney beans. Ugh! I was so excited to make this, so I soldiered on with a random can of chickpeas from the cupboard and I can say that even if with my last minute substitution that this recipe made all the bad parts of Monday disappear. Thanks for an easy, yummy, complex-tasting but easy-to-make dinner. If I could pull off a dinner this good after a day like this, you know it is a genius recipe!
★★★★★
Kate
I am sorry you had a rough Monday, but happy the soup made it a little better :) Thank you so much for your comment and review!
Beth
This turned out great. We are lucky enough to live in an ethnically diverse area, and have several Indian grocery stores nearby. So we used the correct type of lentils. If anyone has a Trader Joe’s nearby, check out their naan in the frozen section. I always get the garlic naan. It heats up beautifully and goes perfectly with this meal.
Nicaela
Hi Beth!
So funny that you mentioned the Trader Joe’s garlic naan. I’m making this recipe right now and picked up some of the naan today. Can’t wait for it to be done cooking!! Gotta love Cookie & Kate and Trader Joe’s!
Eleonore W Stroud
This dal has become one of my favorite recipes ever. It is absolutely delicious, I will have to double the recipe when I make it again in a few days. I didn’t have garam masala on hand so I used curry powder instead and used my immersion blender to make it creamy. Love this recipe!!
★★★★★
Kate
Great! Thank you, Eleonore for your review.
Jennifer W
This is delicious and it was pretty simple to put together. I kept it basic and didn’t add cream, rice or bread this time around. I used my immersion blender in the soup pot and just pulsed it enough times to get some of the soup blended. It is a hearty soup! Made Kate’s broccoli salad as a side item with this soup for lunches this week – was very full!!!
★★★★★
Kate
A great combination, Jennifer! Thanks for sharing how you made it your own and for your review.
Judy
Just made this, and it’s soo good!! I love your technique of blending some of it to make it creamy…looking forward to making more of your delicious recipes!
Kate
Thank you! I think blending really makes all the difference. If you would want to leave a star review since you liked it so much, that would be great!
anna varshavsky
Kate, I recently went back to being a vegetarian. The only thing I eat that’s not from the earth are eggs (sometimes) and goat milk products (which are easily digested, high in protein and low in sugar than cow). I found your blog by chance and it is one of the most amazing rabbit holes I have ever fallen into. I adore your photography, recipes and the stories. They are very much like my own—inspired by travel and people. And, Cookie is adorable and needs to be on display more! Thank you so much. I hope FOOD NETWORK or NYT Cooking snaps you up soon. You’re an amazing talent.
★★★★
Kate
Well, thank you Anna! I really appreciate that. Cookie is precious (and she knows it too!).
Megan
I tried a bite to see if the lentils were done and it tasted amazing! Then I accidentally added a whole (large) lime instead of just a tablespoon and it was really overpowering (I’m blaming mommy brain) I’ll be making it again soon the correcte way ;)
★★★★★
Kate
Yeah, a whole lime wold be a little too much. Let me know what you think when you make it again!
MXD
Thank you for this recipe. It was good, but too watery IMHO. Next time I will try using only 4 cups of water.
Rachel
Made this recipe today! It was exactly what we were hoping for… a delicious dish that was healthier than the restaurant version of this dish. It was quick and easy to make. The only changes I made were I used some veggie broth along with the water and I used an immersion blender so my results weren’t quite as chunky as the posted photos. I served it with brown rice and naan. Oh, and I think it made more than 4 servings, more like 6. (We will have leftovers for lunch!) We will definitely make this again. Thanks for the great recipes- I am eager to try more of your dishes.
★★★★★
Kate
Happy to hear that, Rachel! Thanks for commenting and review.
Meghan
Another amazing vegetarian dinner that won over my meat-loving family (even my 5yo who hates everything I cook on principle). I had to use plain brown lentils but will try it with black lentils next week when my order comes in. Homemade garlic naan rounded the whole meal out nicely. Thank you so much for providing such delicious meals that everyone can love!
★★★★★
Kate
Hooray! That’s great, Meghan. Thanks for your review!
chris
how much coconut milk would u use here?
Kate
Just a splash. 1/4 cup, more or less depending on the desired creaminess. Hope this helps!
Diana
Hi there!
Let me start by saying I LOVE YOUR RECIPES!!
I don’t know if you’ll get this in time for tonight’s dinner, but here it goes…
I just took the plunge and bought a “InstaPot” (not the name brand, but a pressure cooker with all the bells and whistles at Bed Bath & Beyond). The only reason I chose to purchase it last night was because I love using their 20% off coupon and they do not carry the name brand InstaPot, but had one just as fancy-shmancy. So, anyways, I made my first dish last night…mac & cheese and the family loved it.
With ALL that background, I love using your Quick Dal Makhani recipe. How on earth do I convert to a pressure cooker?? Please help!
Kind Regards,
Diana
★★★★★
Kate
Well, thank you Diana! I see you got it to work from your email. :) Thanks for sharing.
Joanne Ash
This recipe is very mild. Next time I’ll add two jalapenos.
Kate
Sure! Add additional spice, if you would like.
Sarah
The flavor was quite good, but using 5 cups of water made it very runny. It was a thin soup instead of a stew. If I make it again, I will use 2 or 3 cups of water.
★★★
Kate
I’m sorry to heat that! Did you blend it? That should thicken it up. Or, it might have been the lentils you used. What type did you use?
Sarah
I did blend it. I used green lentils. I added a bit of rice to the leftovers to help absorb the liquid which worked well. We did like the flavor a lot.
Michelle
We love this recipe in our house (even the kids) and it’s now on regular rotation.
The first time I made it I didn’t have a jalapeño or quite enough black lentils (I substituted 1/4 cup of red and used 4 cups of water). It was creamy and tasted delicious. I sometimes use all black lentils now, and sometimes still substitute some red. I use a jalapeño if I have one. It doesn’t really matter if I tinker a bit, it always tastes good. Easy to make, healthy comfort food with ingredients I have on hand. Thank you Kate for this fabulous recipe!
★★★★★
Kate
You’re so welcome! I love that you are able to play around with this a little bit. Thanks for your review, Michelle!
Dawn
I had never scrolled down this far to see the comment section, or to see that you’re from Kansas City. I’m in the KC area, too, but I first had the dish with relatives in Los Angeles. She looked up a vegan recipe and made this. I have since made it several times and absolutely love it! I add diced carrots to mine. I use all three garnishes: lime, cilantro, and coconut milk. I also don’t use any oil for the onions, etc. and it comes out great! They sweat out their liquids, so they don’t stick. I usually put it over rice, but my son also likes it over pasta. I couldn’t find black lentils at my normal store but the regular ones work great. I don’t bother to puree it either, because I like the texture. I did do it with part of it the first time, and I liked it, but I just don’t take the extra time usually. I always make a double batch for lots of leftovers. :)
★★★★★
Kate
Well, hello Dawn! I’m glad you are making this now too. Thanks for sharing what you do differently! And yes, leftovers are so good.
Chakra
This recipe looks amazing and it’s on our meal plan for the week.
Thanks!
★★★★★
Kate
You’re welcome!
elizabeth
Very good and very easy to make. Not quite the restaurant quality I was looking for but I will still make again.
★★★★
Kate
I’m glad you liked it, even though it wasn’t the quality you thought. What did you feel like was missing from making it restaurant quality in you opinion?
Amalia
Really interesting recipe! I’ve never seen it with jalepenos before. There’s no shortage of this in restaurants nor urad dal where I live, but I prefer homemade. I think fenugreek is in there. Also theres a charcoal brick done up at the end, don’t know if you’ve heard of that. The blending sounds super cool! I’m not dairy free but my daughter is, so I think she’d like to try that, although it’s usually pretty creamy anyway and I just put butter on the top at the end.
Kate
Let me know if you try it!
Ash
This was great — I had a craving for this but didn’t have the funds to order it from my local Indian takeaway (waiting for paydayyyy). This satisfied my craving without taking too long (and probably a healthier version too to be honest!). I used a mix of green and red lentils as I didn’t have black to hand. And I added chilli powder as I didn’t have a fresh chilli in the fridge.
★★★★★
Kate
I’m excited for you! Cravings are real, so I’m glad this one delivered!
Hilary
I had never used black lentils before (easily found at Whole Foods). This recipe was easy to pull together and delicious. The directions, as always, were crystal clear! And like another reader, I was glad to have a chance to use garam masala, a spice I purchased for a recipe a while back that I haven’t repeated.
★★★★★
Kate
I’m glad you loved this recipe and you thought the instructions were helpful!
Heidi
This was easy and yummy. I reduced the water to 4 cups and cooked it in the pressure cooker on high for 15 min. Lentils were perfectly cooked. Needed additional salt (to my taste). Thanks for another great recipe.
★★★★★
Kate
I’m glad you enjoyed it, Heidi!
Colleen
I had trouble finding black lentils in Vancouver Island, but strangely I found Urad Dal in Walmart. I had to purchase an 8lbs bag of them as that was all that was available. Then I had to rinse them, then soak them in hot water overnight, then cook them separately first. I had to adapt the recipe and not add the water, just the lentils and the water they were cooked in, just enough to cover them. Afte doing all that, I followed your recipe and the result is delicious! Thank you for another yummy and healthy recipe!
★★★★★
Kate
I’m glad you found them! That’s a lot of lentils! I’m glad you loved the recipe, Colleen.
ALVARO
At some point, do you drain the mix? It seeks like a lot of water when it finished cooking
Kate
No need to drain!
CAT
I have just made this this afternoon. So after I added the blended two cups it is still very very liquid. Now the one thing I have done differently was I did not have a stove available so I used an electric fry pan and then a slow cooker. That could be making the difference I suppose although the slow cooker has been on the highest setting since the ingredients were put into it. So I am trying to be patient and will leave the slow cooker on for hours to come without the lid in order to reduce the liquid that seems to refuse to cook down. I guess another option might be to add another cup of lentils ?
★★★★
Kate
Thanks for sharing! I’m not sure, I would think the slow cooker(if done long enough) would be ok. How did it turn out? Sorry for my delay!
CAT
So I added 1/2 cup dried kidney beans and 1 cup dried green lentils after rinsing both well. No pre-cooking – already thickening up – will continue cooking this tomorrow and think I have solved the problem. Next time I will cut the amount of water or not use canned kidney beans – use more dried lentils and dried beans if I stick with the 5 cups water. It smells absolutely to die for so am looking forward to his this works out tomorrow.
★★★★
CAT
This was as an addition to my first post but it has not appeared so I assume you are otherwise occupied since it is the weekend. I don’t give up easily when I run into a glitch so will try this on a stove top eventually to see if that is the big difference! The look of yours makes me want to get this right. Thank you for a great list of ingredients and instructions otherwise!
★★★★
Kate
Thanks for sharing, Cat!
Belinda Lopez
Thank you! What a yummy, easy, recipe. I prepped per your instructions, I just let it (slow) cook a little longer… delish! My partner and I love it. I’ll be making more of your recipes in the future.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you for your review, Belinda!
Stephanie
This has become a weekly meal in our house! It’s so easy and delicious, and I think it’s helping me lose weight as part of my meal planning! Gotta love all that fiber. On my third go of this, I ended up adding 1/2 teaspoon of curry powder in addition to the garam masala and it really took it to the next level. I also splurged and added a tablespoon of butter for creaminess (we don’t have a blender), and my husband and I were practically licking our plates clean. Thank you so much for sharing!
★★★★★
Kate
I love that! Thank you for commenting, Stephanie.
Emma
Just bought your book and loving it!! For this recipe I had a question about whether or not to use a lid.Usually when I cook lentils I put on a lid after it has come to a simmer. For this recipe do you use a lid after you have brought it to a simmer and reduce the heat?
Kate
I’m so glad you are loving my cookbook! No need to cover for this one. I hope this helps!
Katherine
I made this recipe last night and absolutely loved it. Even one of our guests who did not like Indian cuisine enjoyed this dish, and no one could believe that it was vegan! We’re in the mountains, so we made do with red lentils (4 cups of water instead of 5, and it finished a bit quicker than this recipe calls for). This recipe is definitely a winner!
★★★★★
Kate
I’m happy you loved it, Katherine! Thanks for your review.
Michelle
Easy, delicious, almost like the “real” thing! I added a bit extra spice and two jalapeños.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you, Michelle!
Bharat Taxi
Thanks for the great tips, will be sure to get on this right away!
★★★★★
Sonia
Hi – I appreciate your efforts and the cultural flexibility for other traditional cuisines but being an Indian I can tell daal makhani is a very specific and prominent dish and it is not how u have described . Definitely you have tried to follow to the best you could but it’s a recipe so specific like a heritage and I did hate to see a regular daal recipe under the name of daal makhani.
Kate
Thank you for your feedback, Sonia. I appreciate it.
Scott S
Served it up over quinoa with a dollop of Greek yogurt. Out of the park. Thanks for another keeper.
★★★★★
Kate
You’re welcome, Scott!
Maria Mcgillewie
Lovely Dahl recipe thank you and a Happy new year
Love from Maria Sean and our mini daschund Monty in Armagh Northern Ireland.
Kristen
I love this blog, but this recipe missed the mark! Took a long time to cook, way too watery (should only have 2-3 cups of water, not five) and lacked flavor (I put many things in to try and compensate). Sad because I really wanted to love this!
★★
Kate
I’m sorry to hear that, Kristen! Thank you for your review and feedback.
Andreanne
Made this along with three other (veggie) curries for friends yesterday (with green lentils)… And this was the favourite all around. As we didn’t have any vegan I added some soured cream that I needed to use and a knob of butter at the end… It was super tasty (but tried it before adding the extra stuff and it was yummy). Loving the blending trick, it’s making it to my list of favs !! Thanks a lot for sharing !!
★★★★★
Vanessa
This was absolutely delicious, and yet so uncomplicated to make! I’m adding this recipe to my favourites list.
Thank you!
★★★★★
Kate
Great to hear, Vanessa! Thanks for your review.
Tillandsia
I was craving a nice creamy dal makhani but didn’t want to put the effort into a two hour cooking slog. This was tasty and enjoyed by all. I did add a half can of coconut milk but I think the blending technique at the end allows for the cream to be an optional ingredient. I did choose to up the heat with a bit of cayenne and smoked praprika.
★★★★
Kate
I’m happy you enjoyed this version! I appreciate the review.
Leslie Carleton
This was so wonderful and hit the spot for my family. Didn’t have kidney beans so used a can of black beans and the French lentils. Just so satisfying and yummy!
★★★★★
Laura Hanson
All your recipes look wonderful. Is it possible to make this without the tomatoes? What could I add to replace that ingredient? I am allergic to tomatoes. Tomatoes are in sooo many recipes!
Kate
Hi Laura! I think you could omit the tomatoes, or add some chopped roasted red pepper for additional flavor. Since this recipe includes the tomato juices, you may need to add another cup of water or so. I do have a listing of tomato-free recipes here (some require modest substitutions). Hope it’s helpful!
Laura Hanson
Thank you!
Robyn
Hi,
Tonight, I made this recipe. Just as I was finishing cooking, we had friends (unexpectedly) come to the back gate to say hi … respecting the 6 foot rule … I served them this meal, with brown basmati and a bottle of tempranillo. Everyone said it was the best, most comforting meal they’d had in days. Made to spec, except I close to doubled the cumin and coriander and added a half tsp of hot sprinkles (a/k/a red pepper flakes).
Thank you Cookie and Kate for letting us feel somewhat normal over some yummy food tonight. XO
★★★★★
Kate
I’m glad this has brought you some comfort! I appreciate your comment and review. Stay safe!
Chris
Excellent recipe. In this time of self-quarantining, I didn’t have all the ingredients — so I used Puy lentils not beluga, black beans not kidney beans, a can of green chillies instead of a fresh jalapeno — and no lime, so I crossed my fingers and used a dash of lemon. And I used heavy cream to finish it off. And instead of 5 cups of water I knew I needed to cut it down — and even the 3 and 3/4 cups I used was too much. Might I suggest you cut down from 5 cups, or at least say add gradually, so one can decide? And, though Puy lentils call for 20 minutes til done, and your recipe calls for 35 — I cooked for 45-50 minutes to cook out the liquid. Once doing that, and for sure blending 2+ cups, it was delicious — and the Puy lentils are such high quality they didn’t become mush. Good level of spice (could be hotter; next time!), good consistency. Oh — and because no naan available anywhere — I used tortillas! I will definitely make again, maybe with the “correct” ingredients — but what I used was fine.
★★★★★
Kate
Look at you being creative in your kitchen! Thanks for sharing how you were able to work with this recipe to use what you had. I appreciate the feedback and review.
Ben
I made this last night, also throwing mung beans into the mix. It’s wonderfully tasty, and easy and inexpensive to cook. Thank you for another great recipe!
★★★★★
Heidi
In the picture there are veggies; looks like diced carrots and peas but here is none in the recipe.
It doesn’t seee, to be as rich as I wanted it to. What can I add?
Kate
The tomatoes and jalapeño pepper may be tricking you! You could add more spices if you like. I always like to add more olive oil at the end for richness in soups. That might help!
Susan D
Just eating this tonight….it’s delicious…..glad I tried it!
★★★★★
Asna
This was fantastic, thank you so much! Adding a bit of cashew cream at the end (in addition to the puree trick) worked incredibly well. The brightness of the lime is absolutely essential!
★★★★★
Kate
You’re welcome, Asna!
Tammy
Thank you – made this for my family last night and everyone liked it.
★★★★★
Kate
I’m happy it was a hit, Tammy! Thanks for sharing.
Dee Dee
Tasted yummy! Mine came out watery though. Maybe I didn’t simmer it on high enough heat? The flavor is great though.
★★★★★
Kate
That would be my assumption, too!
Maggie McReynolds
Somehow I ended up tripling the lentils and tomatoes (feels like there’s another version of this recipe I called up on my phone while cooking that surprised me?). Fortunately, I stopped short of tripling the water at 10 cups – it was still a little soupier than I would like, but that’s easy to adjust next time. With so many lentils, I had to tweak the spices, but I ended up with a delicious, fragrant, easy dal I’ll make again and again, and all that water meant blending it a bit more than suggested to get a thick and creamy texture – all easy to toggle next time. My son ate his rolled in garlic naan with rice like a burrito. I’m gluten-free, so I ate mine in a bowl over brown rice. Props to you, Kate, and to Frontier – I followed your recommendation on the garam masala, and am glad I did. Years ago, I had a can of garam masala from an Indian grocery that I loved, but this was a very close second!
★★★★★
Kate
Oh no! I’m happy you were able to still enjoy it. Thank you for your review, Maggie!
Nancy Oczkowski
This was tasty though not much different than your lentil soup. I was expecting more of a stew consistency. Perhaps 5 cups of water is too much? I think 2 – 3 would have been enough.
★★★
Kate
I’m sorry you didn’t love this one, Nancy! I appreciate your review.
Laura
Made this tonight and only after finishing my dinner did I realize I used black quinoa instead of lentils!!! This is what I get for putting everything in mason jars. It still tasted good but explains a lot.
★★★★★
Michele
This is goooood. I was less excited about it until I saw that I’d forgotten the lime which was a game changer on the taste. Next time I’ll hopefully find black lentils to make it again.
★★★★
Mac
Thanks for sharing, needs some work. Substitute vegetable broth for the water, and try 3 cups instead of 5. It’s far too bland and thin.
★
Monika Ittah
My husband and I spent 2 amazing weeks in India. Literally the day we returned, with spices bought in New Delhi, we attempted to make your version of easy Dal Makhani. It was delicious!! We couldn’t believe how comparable it was to what we had eaten throughout our stay in various restaurants and street food vendors. It has become a favorite of ours.
Lori
Hi Kate,
When you get to the point of letting everything simmer on medium low heat to cook the lentils, am I supposed to do this with my pot uncovered do the extra liquid evaporates? Or do I have to cover the pot with a lid for the 35 min. time?
Thanks for your prompt reply, I am cooking it as I write you right now!!☺️
Kate
Hi! Yes, this is all with pot uncovered. I hope that helps!
Michele
I just made this tonight and it was fantastic. I did add a couple of tablespoons of butter to get more of a “restaurant” taste, but i love that there’s a healthier option available. Thanks so much for posting!
★★★★★
Elizabeth
I made this a few days ago, and it is SO GOOD. I just ate the second to last bowl for lunch and marvelled at how excellent it was. Also, you have it portioned as 4 servings, but I think it’s closer to 6! (And I am no shy eater)
Howard
I love this recipe. Thanks. Mine came out a little more “soupy” looking than the picture. I used brown lentils instead of the Beluga Lentils (didn’t have any). I think this will be an easy fix for next time. The flavor was great!!!!
Love your recipes…… and your site is easy to navigate
★★★★★
Ami
Had to add extra spices for my taste but overall a nice recipe :)
★★★★
Jenn
Loved this! Although the 5 cups of water made it too soupy, even after blending, so I cut that back to 4 cups the second time around. Also on the second pass, used mushroom broth to add umami, instead of the water. Really a simple, nice flavorful dish. Especially with the cilantro, that really ties it all together.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you for sharing! I’m glad you were able to adjust to your tastes.
Laura
My first time cooking lentils, followed the recipe as written and it was soooo delicious! Blending the two cups made all the difference in consistency. Can’t wait to try more of your recipes.
★★★★★
Kristen
This was an incredibly delicious and pretty forgiving recipe. I didn’t have fresh ginger, so I added dried; didn’t have jalapeño, so I minced a small red bell pepper; didn’t have lime, so I left it out; and I substituted low-sodium veggie broth for water, since I had some left over from another recipe. Pureeing two cups’ worth of the mixture made this super creamy without being heavy. I appreciated that it didn’t require any dairy and wasn’t too ambitious for a weeknight. Thanks!
★★★★★
Kate
Happy to hear you were able to make it work with what you had on hand. Thanks for sharing, Kristen!
Kathryn L Ranieri
This dish is delightful! Thank you so much. Kate
★★★★★
Kate
You’re welcome, Kate! I’m happy you enjoyed it.
Carol S.
I just made this and it is delicious. Please let me know if I could freeze it. Your recipes are great! Thanks for creating and sharing!
★★★★★
Meg
Hi Kate,
Thinking about making a double recipe and wondering if it would freeze well?
Thanks
Kate
Hi Meg, I haven’t tried freezing this but I don’t see why not!
Suzy McAllister
I made this today, absolutely delicious as per all of Cookie & Kate recipes that I’ve tried so far.
★★★★★
Kate
Thank you, Suzy! I’m happy you are enjoying my recipes.
Patty
Hi Kate! I made this recipe today and followed the recipe exactly with the exception of cutting the water back to 4 cups based on other comments. The flavor of the soup is great but mine is the color of black bean soup rather than the more attractive reddish brown color in your picture. I’m more about taste than appearance but do you have any idea what may have happened. Thanks, Patty
Kate
Hi Patti, that seems odd. Were any of your ingredients darker?
Salma Lila
can i use whole black bean and add kidney bean and other yellow bean
Hannah
Variations included using tinned lentils (with only 2 1/2 cups water) and way too many chilli flakes… Whoops!
It was so spicy, but so delicious, that we scoffed it down while our eyes watered.
Lesson learnt for next time, as I’ll definitely be making this again!
★★★★★
Salma Lila
can i use a mix of dals , eg. whole black bean, kidney bean, chick peas, yellow dal?
Kate
Hi, you can try it although I haven’t with this recipe. I recommend it as is.
Lauren Cowie
I’m not sure what I did wrong here but this turned out as a watery soup with no flavour
★★
Kate
Hi! I’m sorry to hear that. Did you follow the quantities and add the seasonings? Were your seasonings older by chance?
Glass is a liquid
This soup was so good, hope to make it again
Glass is a liquid
Mark Chadwick
A delightful result from my first attempt at this recipe. Thank you for your work.
★★★★★